Is Yes art? Councilman says no way
By Tommy Hallissey
Alec Diacou's proposal to brand his home borough with a three-story high "installation" along the waterfront near the confluence of the Harlem and East rivers is getting Bronx cheers from his own elected officials.
Mr. Diacou, a Riverdalian, and his partner Dan Smith got positive feedback for their "Yes the Bronx" campaign when they launched it a year ago. But when they unveiled a rendering of its latest extension, Councilman Oliver Koppell gave it the same welcome a Yankee Stadium bleacher bum shows a Red Sox relief pitcher.
Mr. Smith and Mr. Diacou are convinced that giant red letters spelling out "Yes the Bronx" will be a prominent reminder of the way the borough has bounced back from its troubled recent past and Mr. Diacou takes offense at Mr. Koppell's charge that it's nothing more than a garish sign. "It's an installation; it's a sculpture; it's a piece of art," he said. "It's anything but a sign. It's supposed to be iconographic."
The installation will be hard to miss: it will be three stories tall and a block long in bright red. The cost is estimated to be between $2 and $3 million, depending on material used. The creators haven't decided yet if it will be double-faced, to be read from both the Bronx and Manhattan sides, but Mr. Smith is certain it needs to be visible at the top of the Triboro Bridge. A prototype is still in the works.
"It's going to have all the connotations and aesthetics of a great sculpture," said Mr. Smith, a branding expert.
But Mr. Koppell stands firm in his opposition to the sign based on his viewing of a rendering. "You want something to have elegance not just be an advertisement," he said.
He cited a topiary hedge in Great Barrington, Mass., which is clipped in the shape of the town's initials — GB. He called the hedge "refined" and "elegant." For the councilman the Yes the Bronx rendering conjured up images of the infamous Hollywood sign in California. "I don't know if Hollywood is the image we want to exude," he said, adding the Bronx rendering looked "brassy" and "bold."