Distasteful opinion? Let's hear it!

Posted

Among the letters to the editor and opinion articles we receive from readers every week, there is occasionally a piece expressing views that most of us at The Press strongly oppose or even find unsettling. Moreover, occasionally there is a letter that we think may upset a significant number of our readers.

Every time that happens, we face a difficult question: Should we publish the letter, giving our readers a chance to have their voices heard—or should we decline publication, to avoid the risk of upsetting some other readers?

It has been our policy to decline publishing a letter if we find it racist, libelous or just heinously mean-spirited, or a letter that advocates for illegal or violent actions. But such outrageous cases are rare. A more common case is a letter that steers clear of any of the offenses listed above, but expounds a view that many of our readers may find distasteful and disturbing.

A possible example of that is a letter this week by Alvin Gordon about immigration and “illegal aliens.” A vast majority of Riverdale residents hold politically and socially liberal views, and many are likely to take issue with Republican and conservative views on immigration or with a verbal onslaught against undocumented immigrants. Some readers may take offense. A few may feel outraged.

Yet we still believe that socially conservative readers have the right to express their views, even if those readers are in a minority in Riverdale. And they have the right to have their views respected—but perhaps disputed, debated and disproven.

We published Alvin Gordon’s letter this week, as we had published other letters that some of our readers had found objectionable in the past. Although having a letter published is a privilege, we believe we should extend this privilege broadly and generously, and have done so. From time to time, a reader would get so angry that he or she would call to protest or to cancel a subscription. That’s a price we have to pay.

Many conservative commentators have accused the mainstream press of refusing to publish conservative views. Many conservatives accuse the press of censorship. We do not want to furnish evidence to validate such claims—and so, we publish our readers’ letters, regardless of the political views expressed in them.

One of the factors that helped Donald Trump get elected as president was the belief held by many socially conservative Americans that they could not get their views heard, except through a few fringe outlets and alt-right websites, which even many of President Trump’s supporters find distasteful. We do not want to uphold such perception of censorship—and so, we offer our readers a platform to express their views.

We hope that when our readers come across a view they find upsetting or one that stokes anger, the readers would respond by writing letters to dispute the views they found objectionable.

Comments

1 comment on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment
CelticWoman

I find it laughable that many in Riverdale consider themselves liberal. Actually, it's hysterical. Not to mention hypocritical.

Those who reside in Riverdale must admit to themselves WHY they live "up the hill" as opposed to living along Broadway. Or Sedgwick Avenue. Or why many Riverdale residents moved there from areas of the Bronx and Manhattan. I know many who moved out (or rather ran out) of Inwood to Riverdale because let's face it - Inwood isn't safe and Riverdale is. Why is that? Well, there's a little immigration problem in Inwood and I'm not referring to the Irish. Seems too many who run for the ivory tower areas such as Riverdale forget this. They don't want their snowflakes to be accosted by someone a few shades darker than themselves nor do they want to be subjected to hood rats that don't work, teenage mothers, loud music at 3am, crime, filth and everything else that goes along with it.

Illegals are a problem in NYC and the rest of the country. This is a fact. Until Riverdale - and I'm referring to Riverdale Avenue and Fieldston - get their own taste of it, don't judge others and their opinions. Live it first.

Tuesday, April 18 | Report this