Stop focusing so much on cigarette sales

To the editor:

Mayor Bill de Blasio’s proposal to raise the cost of a pack of cigarettes from $10.50 to $13, just like past increases, will not discourage consumption.

The growth of the so-called illegal street corner, bodega and deli cigarette sales known as “loosies” two for $1, will rise in proportion to periodic government increases in taxes on the purchase of cigarettes.

This once again will occur if Mayor de Blasio’s proposal is passed by the city council and becomes law.

Many consumers will just travel past the city line to stores selling cigarettes in neighboring Connecticut, Nassau County, New Jersey and Westchester communities to patronize stores offering lower prices. 

Both the city and state will see an increase in the loss of millions in uncollected tax revenues. Why sell hard drugs when you can sell cigarettes with virtually no penalties? Consumption of tobacco has been part of mainstream America, transcending generations. 

Despite the best efforts of government to limit consumption via excessive taxes and smoking restrictions, just like alcohol prohibition in the 1920s — both are doomed to failure. These actions infringe on citizens’ civil and economic liberties.

Creative entrepreneurs will always provide what citizens desire, regardless of government approval. Consumers have voted with their dollars, making tobacco consumption a multi-billion-dollar enterprise today.

Our tax dollars would be better used if police and judges spend more time prosecuting those who commit real crimes against individuals or property than going after those who sell “loosies.” Law enforcement authorities should be free to pursue those who commit real crimes against citizens and property.

At 18, you are old enough to vote, be a parent, pay taxes, own a car, take out a bank loan, serve in the military and die for your country — but not consume tobacco.

This makes no sense.

LARRY PENNER