Newburgh Four bases appeal on entrapment
By Adam Wisnieski
Three judges in a federal Manhattan appeals court are currently considering whether the four men convicted of plotting to blow up the Riverdale Jewish Center and Riverdale Temple were entrapped by the government.
At an appeal hearing on Nov. 5, attorneys for the Newburgh Four — convicted in October 2010 and later sentenced to 25 years in prison — argued that the government engaged in misconduct when Federal Bureau of Investigation informant Shahed Hussain enticed the men with money and provided supplies for the plot. Lawyers argue the FBI informant, not the Newburgh Four, came up with the idea of attacking the synagogues and so the guilty verdicts should be overturned.
James Cromitie, Laguerre Payen, Onta Williams and David Williams were arrested May 20, 2009 in Riverdale, after trying to plant explosives outside the two synagogues.
After an eight-week trial and eight days of deliberations, all four men were convicted on Oct. 18, 2010 of conspiracy to use weapons of mass destruction within the U.S.; three counts of attempting to use weapons of mass destruction within the U.S.; conspiracy to acquire and use anti-aircraft missiles; attempting to acquire and use anti-aircraft missiles and conspiracy to kill officers and employees of the U.S.
In addition to trying to blow up the Riverdale synagogues, they were also found guilty of planning to shoot missiles at military planes located at Stewart Air National Guard Base near Newburgh, N.Y.
As the trial progressed, what was first perceived as a major victory for law enforcement became something of an embarrassment. Judge Colleen McMahon said the accused would have been unlikely to pursue terrorism without prodding from federal agents and an informant looking to manufacture an arrest.
While Judge McMahon said during the trial that she was not proud of how the government handled the case, she sentenced each man to 25 years in prison, the mandatory minimum sentence for the conviction.
“Only the government could have made a ‘terrorist’ out of Mr. Cromitie, whose buffoonery is positively Shakespearean in its scope,” she said at the sentencing.
KeywordsAdam Wisnieski, politics, Newburgh Four, entrapment, Riverdale Jewish Center, Riverdale Temple,