'You are in our house'

Convention vote sparks fiery debate at Dems club


There wasn’t much agreement at last week’s meeting of the Benjamin Franklin Reform Democratic Club. 

In fact, most of the two-hour meeting was drowned in shouting matches between representatives from Citizens Union — an activist group rallying support for a referendum on whether the state should hold a constitutional convention — and some of the tried and true Democrats of the northwest Bronx. 

Both Tom Bergdall of Citizens Union and Paul Egan of the United Federation of Teachers — along with the questioners and commentators that followed them — told a story about a dysfunctional state government in Albany, a federal government in Washington that threatened the liberal existence of New York as a liberal bastion, and the desperate need for a fix. 

It was, however, which magic pill would fix those issues they really disagreed on. Bergdall and his Citizens Union colleague Priscilla Grim said New York needed a radical approach: Hold a constitutional convention, and make the necessary changes to government. 

A constitutional convention — which automatically appears on New York state ballots every 20 years — would mean electing 204 delegates to go to Albany and rewrite the state’s constitution. 

The convention has been touted by advocates as a fast way to make necessary changes to government codified within the constitution, adding long-advocated laws like same-day voting registration and ethical reform for elected officials. And while lawmakers themselves could be named as delegates to the convention, this process would bypass the Assembly and senate in Albany who Bergdall and Grim say haven’t been getting the job done.

“It’s not going to be any different whether you take the long road or the short road,” Bergdall said. “The existing politicians like things the way they are.” 

Egan and some of the Ben Franklin Club’s opponents of the referendum — which will appear as the largest ballot item this November — would like a different approach, one they have been touting for years: Elect more Democrats. 

“Let’s imagine this like a game of poker — let’s take all of our rights and put them all in the middle and hope that they all come back on the other side,” Egan said. “Why aren’t we going to the current politicians and telling them what we want? It is just a massive risk.”

But the disagreements at the Sept. 27 meeting weren’t just ideological. In many cases, they got very personal. 

That was especially true for Grim, who got into several intense shouting matches with Ben Franklin Club members, including Assemblyman Jeffrey Dinowitz and Community Board 8 member Marvin Goodman. A fierce advocate for a “yes” vote in November, Grim interrupted several people during the questions section of the meeting — namely Goodman — a few times. During the same session, Grim was shouted down by members of the club for trying to make a comment instead of asking a question. 

At the time, Goodman — who had previously tried to make a comment but was told he couldn’t by the meeting’s moderator — joined in on the shouting. 

“If I wasn’t allowed to make a comment, why can she?” he shouted. 

By the time the meeting opened for comments, Grim volunteered to speak for the convention, but was interrupted and, again, shouted down by club members who said she couldn’t make a statement, since she wasn’t a member of the club. 

 Grim said she had never felt she had a voice in government before, “So why should I now?” But the most serious moment of the meeting came when Dinowitz — typically known for his sarcasm and wit, though not his temper — finally had enough being interrupted. 

“You are in our house,” the assemblyman yelled as he stepped toward Grim. “You will behave.”

In the end, though, it seemed all of Grim’s efforts to impose her ideas on the Ben Franklin Club were in vain. The club — which often is touted as one of the most influential and active political clubs in the Bronx — voted 30-2 against endorsing the constitutional convention. 

Given Egan’s comments earlier in the night regarding the dismal 14 percent voter turnout in citywide primaries Sept. 12, there is no telling how many people will actually show up to the polls in November. But it is certain the vast majority of Ben Franklin Club voters who do make it to the polls won’t be looking to support Bergdall’s “magic pill.”


2 comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment
John Nimby

Mrs. Nimby goes bonkers when I say this but our only hope is the Republicans. The Democrats are in the pocket of those who don't care if the State is falling apart as long as they get their Almighty pensions. Vote YES on CON-CON.

| Friday, October 6, 2017
Democraop 4 life

Having the most corrupt and unscrupulous and raciest members of our society AKA democratic party I think we need to raise personal income tax by 30% so we cab give free housing and free food and free medical to the invaders that the Donald wants to stop sponging off us.

Lets put our money where our mouth is so people such as HELLery Clinton will no longer be broke

Lets give all civil servants (city employees) their full salary plus free medical for life after 15 years so we can have them retire and hire new people

under the affirmative action act

Knowing the empty buildings on 261 street and Riverdale ave will make a perfect methadone clinic plus a homeless shelter for ex convicts will show every one in NYS how we liberal Democratic party members do not mind higher taxes as lord knows we deserve a huge tax increase so Dinbat assemblyman and bad teeth Engel can get a huge raise .

Mark Stagg is correct by dumping homeless people in Riverdale and we need more developers like him to help build more no income housing

Our mayor should look into Vanny park as there is really to much unused land there and a few high rise section 8 only apartment buildings would be a Mitvah for this area

Friday, October 6, 2017