Running Broadway homeless shelter costs $14,000 a day


Running a transitional homeless facility for more than 80 families is not a cheap proposition.

In fact, according to the contract, city officials could approve as early as Aug. 17, the proposed facility at 5731 Broadway will cost taxpayers $5.3 million a year, or more than $63,600 per family.

Only a portion of that money — $2.4 million — will go toward actual rent, however, with the rest earmarked for a number of social service programs, building maintenance and security.

“High-quality transitional housing is far more than just a room to sleep in or a roof over one’s head,” said Isaac McGinn, spokesman for the city’s homeless services department. “To help homeless New Yorkers get back on their feet across the five boroughs, we connect clients every day with robust wraparound resources including case management, housing placement assistance, programming for children, health and mental services, and employment counseling on-site.”

Those services aren’t free, however. 

Praxis Housing Initiatives, which would manage 5731 Broadway on behalf of the city, plans to hire three social workers and three case managers, according to a draft copy of the contract. Each social worker would make $55,000 a year, while case managers would earn a bit less at $41,000. 

They would join two housing specialists (at $40,000 each) and a programming director for $67,000.

5731 Broadway also would employ a recreational activities coordinator for $43,000, and a part-time peer educator for $17,500. 

All of them would be managed by the site director, slated to earn $75,000 each year, who will work with a benefits specialist earning $40,000.

The 83 units, according to DHS, are primarily one-bedroom apartments. However, a little more than a dozen of them are actually two-bedroom apartments, while 18 of them are studios.

The average rent for the units works out to $2,400 per month, according to the contract. By comparison, an 890-square-foot one-bedroom, one-bath apartment near 5731 Broadway was listed Tuesday for $1,575 per month on the popular real estate site Zillow.

Another unit at 235 Naples Terrace was listed on the same website for just under $2,300 per month. However, that unit is advertised with three bedrooms and a single bathroom.

Both units are considerably older than what’s at 5731 Broadway, however, considering the transitional housing site is finishing construction now.

Utilities, by the way, are contracted for $360,000 per year, or more than $360 per month per unit.

During a Community Board 8 meeting last month, Praxis officials said they would hire more than a dozen security officers to man 5731 Broadway. In fact, the contract calls for 14 security guards earning $32,000 each, plus one supervisor coming in at $57,000. 

In all, security personnel alone will cost the city just under $450,000 each year.

The final contract between DHS and Praxis must be approved by the Mayor’s Office of Contract Services, which will review the entire project Aug. 17 at 10 a.m., at 1 Centre St., Mezzanine, in Manhattan.

The public is allowed to speak at the meeting, but it will require some advance planning. Comments are limited to three minutes, and speakers have to bring three copies of their statements to distribute to the contract committee.

The contract services office also has made the draft agreement available for public inspection. However, it does require a trip to 4 World Trade Center in Manhattan, and an appointment that can be scheduled by calling the city’s human resources administration office.

In all, 35 people are expected to work at 5731 Broadway. That’s a total payroll of $1.4 million annually, and fringe benefits costing more than $350,000. 

CB8 has blasted the proposal to open transitional housing for the homeless at 5731 Broadway, instead asking for more permanent accommodations.

As part of the city’s new homeless plans, DHS said it would close its operations at the nearby Van Cortlandt Motel by the end of the year.


3 comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment

I hate to sound so unfair as a minority and parent myself. The new tenants set to move in to this brand new housing facility are at the moment being housed at the Deegan Motel on Broadway. A block away from my home and Bus stop I ride every morning. I myself, personally come across some of these individuals on a daily basis. Very few honest families. The rest... while waiting for the bus with their children I have witness rolling marijuana, Other times while walking my dog past the Deegan Motel I have witnessed not on just one occasion mostly every morning drugged up individuals who can barely stand. I overheard a conversation of a couple while pushing their stroller figuring out how they would gather the money to buy drugs. On another occasion I had one of the females in my buildings lobby begging for change. The garbage, used condom wrappers, beer cans, Chinese food container all contaminate my tree lined block. I am all for giving ppl chances but being that this is my neighborhood. I moved to my area to provide my daughter with a better quality of life. So as a parent I didnt agree with the cities plan to use this new development to house unemployed individuals. I dont know all the details but I hope that one of the requirements is for them to find some sort of employment.

| Wednesday, August 16, 2017

Why is so much security needed? Is there something we should know about the population that will be housed here?

If these are just ordinary run-of-the mill families who are financially unable to afford housing, there should be no need for such Rikers Island type security over here at such great expense to the taxpayers.

Thursday, August 17, 2017
Michael Hinman

Please do not attack other posters or other readers in these comments. Talk about the issues, not each other.

Friday, August 18, 2017